Black White
Friday, November 13th, 2009
Black, White, and Spot Color
Amidst the little brouhaha of last month, I received an email from a Cheap Seats reader that I couldn’t get out of my head:
I’m an African-American with a Masters in Marketing. I have been in the advertising industry now for about 6 years. I’ve been interviewing at many of the larger agencies in New York City for an Account Services position for sometime now with no success.
At every interview Human Resource personnel and Account Service people constantly tell me of their commitment to diversity in the industry and within their own agencies. But when I look around these agencies everyone, aside from the janitors, is white.
My question is why is it so difficult for so many people of color to get ahead at a general market advertising agency? With Latinos counted as the largest minority in America and the combined spending power of African Americans and Latinos, is this pigment less trend bound to change? And why is it like this in the first place?
I felt rather honored that he chose to tell me his story. But how could I respond?
Because I, Whitey O’Cracker, am only a few years and a few cheeseburgers away from a being a fat old white man myself. As much as I can sympathize with the guy’s job-seeking frustrations, I just can’t put myself in his shoes.
I didn’t have any easy answers for him, but I did pose a few guesses.
First, consider the history of the ad biz. Advertising agencies in the early days were founded on relationships. In Randall Rothenberg’s “Where the Suckers Moon,” he illustrates how the old shops like J. Walter Thompson resembled country clubs–sort of WASPs only, so that their clients would feel comfortable that their account was in good hands. All of which began to change in the 60′s with agencies like DDB, started by Irish guys and Jewish guys. So as corporate America evolved, advertising did, too.
But it’s still a relationship business–read ADWEEK and you’ll see lots of higher-ups change jobs to work with people they worked with in the past. Which tends to keep outsiders, uh, outside. It’s a cycle that keeps perpetuating itself over the years.
I was also under the impression that the largest agencies, especially the big NYC ones, would have the most resources to find, recruit and train more minorities. But according to this reader, that may not be the case. And if NYC is the most diverse city in the world, what hope is there for ad agencies in, say, Denver or St. Louis?
I’ve never been in the position of having to hire anyone. I have participated in interviewing people, and I’ll never forget after an Asian art director came to interview and my Creative Director said later, “Well, there’s your diversity.” As if one Asian could balance out 30 honkies. But you have to start somewhere, right?
Plus, a more diverse workforce in an ad agency will result in a major change to its internal culture. Advertising people tend to be very loose-lipped and politically incorrect in meetings and conversations. Which is easier to do when you’re not afraid of offending anyone in the room. In other words, more diversity means more sensitivities to watch out for. Kinda takes the fun out of stereotyping people all day long, doesn’t it?
The bottom line is, well, the bottom line. Ad agencies are too tightly staffed to go out of their way to recruit minorities the way FORTUNE 500 companies and others might. Plus, there is no job security for anyone–and agencies who layoff people on a somewhat regular basis might be opening themselves up to discrimination lawsuits if those layoffs include minorities. There may be some good old-fashioned CYA happening there.
Agencies these days are not proactive–they’re reactive. If clients demand that the agency staff reflect the makeup of their audience, then you might see things change. But it won’t happen just because some agency CEO makes a speech at an industry conference or some equal opportunity line gets thrown into a classified ad. It’ll happen one person at a time, one interview at a time, one position at a time.
Like I said, I don’t think the answers are easy ones. Our society, and our industry, may simply never be able to truly look past someone’s looks. But it’s important to keep the conversation going. Because when it comes to matters of black, white and any other skin color—it’s all one big grey area, isn’t it?
About the Author
Branding. Religion. Censorship. Office politics. Global politics. Sexual politics. And getting drunk during a job interview.
Since 2002, Danny G. (a.k.a. Dan Goldgeier) has been writing the most provocative advertising columns ever published. They’re all witty, thoughtful and probing, and a must read for those who want a perspective rarely seen in traditional industry publications.
An Atlanta-based copywriter and ad school graduate, Dan has worked at shops big and small. He reads incessantly about advertising, and is a whiz at rock & roll trivia. Learn more about him by visiting his copywriting website or AdColumnist.com, the View From The Cheap Seats Archive website. You may also find articles by Danny G at TalentZoo.com.
Michael Jackson – Black Or White
|
|
Vintage CHANEL Gold Tone/Black + White Pearls- Drop Design Clip Earrings-c 1992 $284.99 |
|
|
NEW RALPH LAUREN NAUTICAL WHITE & DIAGONAL BLACK STRIPE A-LINE KNEE SKIRT 2 $127.99 |
|
|
New Glass Crystal 4*40w Lamps Chandelier Fabric Shade Black/White/Orange/Wine $116.00 |
|
|
B&W Photo S4472 Boy in jeans on picnic bench $5.98 |
|
|
NEW White Auto Mechanical Black Leather Wrist Watch Self Winding High Quality $1.56 |
|
|
B & W K0228 Man standing under car on lift $5.98 |
|
|
GENUINE Pokemon 7″ VICTINI STOUTLAND Plush Figure Doll Toy BANPRESTO B&W $19.99 |
|
|
Fine Carved Cloud Pattern Cross Necklace Pendant Black White Stainless Steel $5.39 |
|
|
Size 8 White House Black Market 100% Silk Aline Lined Dress Sleeveless M $30.34 |
|
|
14k White Gold Black Diamond Stripe Cocktail Fashion Band Ring Unique Wide SZ 7 $1,108.00 |
|
|
Reebok Pump Fury Safety Pack Gold Yellow/Black-White $135.00 |
|
|
Reebok Pump Fury Safety Pack Gold Yellow/Black-White $135.00 |
|
|
Reebok Pump Fury Safety Pack Gold Yellow/Black-White $135.00 |
|
|
Reebok Pump Fury Safety Pack Gold Yellow/Black-White $135.00 |
|
|
Reebok Pump Fury Safety Pack Gold Yellow/Black-White $135.00 |
|
|
HANDMADE GLASS BY VIOKEF 6” TALL WHITE & BLACK SPATTER PATTERN GLOBE $50.00 |
|
|
GENUINE POKEMON ZEKROM DX Figure Best Wishes Doll BANPRESTO B&W Toy $9.99 |
|
|
Mini Audio Wireless Micro The Microphone Recorder fr iPhone 4 3GS Black White $3.12 |
|
|
GENUINE POKEMON RESHIRAM DX Figure Best Wishes Doll BANPRESTO B&W Toy $9.99 |
|
|
Stanzino Women’s Strapless Black and White with Stud Top Cute Sexy Fashion Wear $19.50 |
|
|
Stanzino Women’s Strapless Black and White with Stud Top Cute Sexy Fashion Wear $19.50 |
|
|
NEW! Sexy BOHEMIAN White LINEN & Black EMBROIDERED Top by MARISA CHRISTINA ~ MED $7.95 |
|
|
Nike black with white detail pants size XL $5.27 |
|
|
Womens Size 18 Black & White Swim Suit New W Built In Shorts NICE FREE SHIP $24.95 |
|
|
FRED ASTAIRE #2 B/W PHOTO DANCING ON STANGE TUXEDO $2.95 |
|
|
GENUINE BANPRESTO Pokemon Halloween AXEW Kibago Pokedoll Plush Doll B&W Japan $15.99 |
|
|
Pokemon Black and White 1 by Hidenori Kusaka (2011, Pap $14.99 |
|
|
Vintage Earrings BLACK & WHITE USA Estate 100s in Store wp $14.00 |
|
|
Pokemon Black and White by Hidenori Kusaka (2012, Paper $14.99 |
|
|
4 VERY FANCY BLACK AND WHITE HAT PINS $22.00 |
|
|
Pokemon Black and White 4 by Hidenori Kusaka (2011, Pap $14.99 |
|
|
Nike “Nikebook Dunk Low Black&White Boys 7 Youth $8.99 |
|
|
Pokemon Black and White 2 by Hidenori Kusaka (2011, Pap $14.99 |
|
|
GENUINE BANPRESTO Pokemon Halloween PIKACHU Pokedoll Plush Doll Toy B&W Japan $17.99 |
|
|
B & W K0229 Men working on trailer $5.98 |
|
|
B&W Photo S4473 Kids sleeping in beds $5.98 |
|
|
Joseph A. Animal Striped Print Black & White Cardigan Sweater Size L, NWT $29.95 |
|
|
Pokemon Black and White by Hidenori Kusaka (2012, Paper $14.99 |
|
|
Caribbean Joe Floral Swimsuit Tankini Top Black White 8 $19.99 |
|
|
GENUINE BANPRESTO Pokemon Halloween MINCCINO Chillarmy Pokedoll Plush Doll B&W $14.99 |
|
|
Simple Style Retro Square Stud New Earrings $5.48 |
|
|
HANDMADE GLASS BY VIOKEF 6” TALL WHITE & BLACK SPATTER PATTERN GLOBE $50.00 |
|
|
Black & White Jasper Pendant Bead G117842 $3.80 |
|
|
Stanzino Women’s White Black Printed Dress with Beaded Straps $22.75 |
|
|
GENUINE BANPRESTO Pokemon Halloween PURRLOIN Choroneko Pokedoll Plush Doll B&W $15.99 |
|
|
AMAZING VINTAGE BLACK & WHITE ROCKABILLY DRESS KAPPI 1970′s / 1980′s (?) $9.99 |
|
|
Stanzino Women’s White Black Printed Dress with Beaded Straps $22.75 |
|
|
White AND BLACK OTTERBOX DEFENDER SERIES CASE FOR APPLE IPHONE 4 4 G 4S 4 S $16.99 |
|
|
Stanzino Women’s Black White Printed Dress with Beaded Straps New Sexy $22.75 |
|
|
Stanzino Women’s Black White Printed Dress with Beaded Straps New Sexy $22.75 |
|
|
Presto 114316 04820 PopLite Hot Air Corn Popper $29.99 Plug in Prestos PopLite and the party begins. In less than 2.5 minutes you will have up to 18 cups which is equal to two large bowlfuls of fluffy popcorn with virtually no unpopped kernels. And because the machine uses hot air instead of oil the resulting snack is healthier and lower in calories. Thats not to say you can nott add butter in fact the half cup measuring cup on top of the popper doubl… |
|
|
Whirlpool PUR Side by Side Refrigerator Push Button Cyst Reducing Water Filter … |
|
|
Hamilton Beach 51101B Personal Blender with Travel Lid, Black $21.99 Hamilton Beach Single Serve Blenders feature durable stainless steel blades that blend your favorite drinks in seconds. Use the travel cup to blend drinks to go anytime, or fill the whole jar with fresh ingredients for family and friends. Cleanup couldn’t be simpler place the cup or blending jar right in the dishwasher.Manufacturer: Hamilton Beach Brands, IncManufacturer Part Number: … |
|
|
It Might Get Loud $8.33 The Sony DVD It Might Get Loud is an epic, exhilarating backstage pass into the world of rock stars. There are guitar players, and then there are rock stars. Over the course of one day, three generations of electric guitar phenoms come together, crank up their amps, and let it roll.Documentarian Davis Guggenheim gives us so much more than an all-star jam session (that alone would make even the gna… |
|
|
The White Album $12.97 Better known as the “White Album,” this was meant to be the record that brought them back to earth after three years of studio experimentation. Instead, it took them all over the place, continuing to burst the envelope of pop music. Lennon and McCartney were still at the height of their powers, with Lennon in particular growing into one of rock’s towering figures. But even McCartney could still ro… |
|
|
Facing Future $10.66 All products are BRAND NEW and factory sealed. Fast shipping and 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed…. |
|
|
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (Three-Disc Diamond Edition Blu-ray/DVD Combo + BD Live w/ Blu-ray packaging) $37.98 Studio: Buena Vista Home Video Release Date: 10/06/2009… |
|
|
Summer with Monika (The Criterion Collection) [Blu-ray] $27.99 Inspired by the earthy eroticism of his muse Harriet Andersson (Through a Glass Darkly), in the first of her many roles for him, Ingmar Bergman (Wild Strawberries) had a major international breakthrough with this ravaging, sensual tale of young love. In Stockholm, a girl (Andersson) and boy (The Magician’s Lars Ekborg) from working-class families run away from home to spend a secluded, romantic su… |
|
|
Summer Interlude (The Criterion Collection) [Blu-ray] $19.99 Touching on many of the themes that would define the rest of his legendary career-isolation, performance, the inescapability of the past-the tenth film by Ingmar Bergman (The Seventh Seal) was a gentle sway toward true mastery. In one of the director’s great early female roles, Maj-Britt Nilsson (To Joy) beguiles as Marie, an accomplished ballet dancer haunted by her tragic youthful affair with a … |
|
|
Black & Decker Pivot Vac 18V Cordless Pivoting Hand Vac, PHV1810 $40.58 Exclusive 10 position pivoting nozzle provides ultimate vacuuming accessability up high, down low, and in between. Integrated extension nozzle for 50% more reach in tight areas. 18V of power and strong motor provides 35% more suction power. Cylonic action filter stays clean so that suction power stays longer. EZ Clean wheel system instantly improves suction power. 3 stage filtration provides clean… |
|
|
Sterling Silver Pink, Black, White Crystal Ring $43.99 Pink, black, white crystal ringSterling silver jewelryClick here for ring sizing guide. |
|
|
10k Gold 1/8ct TDW Black/ White Diamond Bone Necklace $136.99 Whimsical bone-shape pendant sparkles with black and white diamondsNecklace makes an excellent gift for the dog-lover in your lifeJewelry is crafted of gleaming 10-karat white gold |
|
|
Platinum Ties Men’s Striped ‘Black & White’ Tie $21.99 This handsome Black & White tie from Platinum Ties features durable polyester construction with a high-quality look and feel. This black tie features a white striped pattern. |
|
|
Murano-style Glass Black, White and Gold Leaf Earrings $11.49 These Murano-inspired earrings will give the perfect artistic touch to any wardrobe. Adorn yourself with the vibrant color of these handcrafted glass earrings in a leaf shape accented with black, gold and white. |
|
|
Cotton and Fused Glass Black/ White Wavy Disk Necklace (Chile) $16.99 A disk of bubble glass is embedded in a disk of opaque black glass with white waves in this striking pendant necklace. The pendant hangs from two adjustable silken cords that are skillfully knotted with glass beads. |
|
|
Cotton and Fused Glass Black/ White Wavy Line Trapezoid Necklace (Chile) $17.89 A trapezoid of bubble glass is embedded in a trapezoid of opaque black glass with white waves in this striking pendant necklace. The pair of adjustable silken cords for this piece of jewelry skillfully knotted with glass beads. |
|
|
Preston ‘Black & White Palms’ Canvas Art $112.99 Artist: Eric MullTitle: Black & White PalmsProduct type: Gallery-wrapped canvas |
|
|
Pillow Perfect Outdoor Black/ White Polka Dot Wicker Loveseat Cushion $44.99 Color: Black/whitePattern: Polka dotMaterials: 100-percent polyester |
|
|
MANHATTAN 150194 2.0 Speaker System – Black, White $69.8 MANHATTAN 150194 2.0 Speaker System – Black, White |
|
|
ECO STYLE Saigon Carrying Case for iPad – Black, White $33.49 ECO STYLE Saigon Carrying Case for iPad – Black, White |
|
|
Orlimar SLX OR99214 Carrying Case for Golf – Silver, Black, White $53.99 Orlimar SLX OR99214 Carrying Case for Golf – Silver, Black, White |
|
|
Pillow Perfect Outdoor Black/ White Polka Dot Tufted Loveseat Cushion $53.56 Color: Black/whitePattern: Polka dotMaterials: 100-percent polyester |
|
|
Zalman ZM-HDR1 Storage Enclosure – Internal – Black, White $51.49 Zalman ZM-HDR1 Storage Enclosure – Internal – Black, White |
|
|
Swan Hat Women’s Black/White Synamay Hat $59.99 This black/white summer synamay hat by Swan is elegant, distinguished and feminine. This hat is constructed with the finest straw synamay, embellished with multicolored satin band and feathers. |
|
|
Swan Hat Black/White Synamay Summer Hat $59.99 This Black/White Summer Synamay hat by Swan is elegant, distinguished and feminine. This hat is constructed with the finest straw synamay, embellished with multicolored satin band and feathers. The brim measures 6 1/2 inches. |
|
|
Bleek2Sheek Glass Pearl Bead Stretch Bracelet $10.99 Let this versatile stretch bracelet adorn your look for a dressy night out on the town or out and about. The bracelet features black, white and grey glass pearl beads and crystal rhinestones filaments. |
|
|
Pillow Perfect Outdoor Black/ White Polka Dot Chaise Lounge Cushion $76.64 Color: Black/ White Polka Dot Materials: 100-percent polyesterFill: Polyester fiber fill |
|
|
Pillow Perfect Outdoor Black/ White Polka Dot Round Chair Cushion $51.87 Color: Black/White Polka DotMaterials: 100-percent polyesterFill: Polyester fiber fill |
|
|
Betsy Brown ‘Black & White Centerpiece I & II’ Framed Print Art $173.99 Artist: Betsy Brown Title: Black & White Centerpiece I & IIProduct type: Framed print art |
|
|
Kathie McCurdy ‘Dandelion Black & White’ Canvas Art $137.99 Artist: Kathie McCurdyTitle: Dandelion Black & WhiteProduct Type: Gallery-wrapped canvas art |